10. Tales of Glory. Narratives of Roman Victory
Friday, 26 August 2022, Steigerzaal
Session Chairs: Martina Meyr & Christof Flügel
Affiliation: Städtische Museen Rottweil, Germany
Affiliation of co-organiser: Landesstelle für die nichtstaatlichen Museen in Bayern, Germany
Session Abstract: Since the groundbreaking research of Paul Zanker and Tonio Hölscher it has been generally acknowledged, how deliberately chosen images influenced the public perception of political and military power in Rome. The “power of images” (Paul Zanker), however, soon entered the private realm and was subject of alterations regarding the “reading of these images”, as e.g. illustrated by middle Imperial Roman wedding rings with the dextrarum iunctio, a motif which had been originally limited to emphasize the unity of the army in times of Civil War. The significance of this symbol had changed, from public to private. Images of the triumphant rider, an image originally confined to the Emperor, were used in gemstones and on private funerary monuments.
Zanker’s and Hölscher’s ideas were, however, never extensively applied to the art and to small finds in the Roman provinces. Concentrating on the example of Roman victory and how this topic was communicated in Rome and at the Edge of Empire, we therefore explicitly welcome contributions from all fields of archaeology, including Classical and Roman Provincial Archaeology, as well as Numismatics, Epigraphy and Ancient History. Especially questions of how these images were used in the provinces and what mechanisms and means of distribution were used are of particular interest, but also papers on public rituals of victory in Rome and her provinces and on the “propaganda use” of the public realm will be appreciated.
- Breeze, D., 2016: They think it’s all over. The face of victory on the British frontier, Journal of Conflict Archaeology 11/1, 19-39. (http://dx.doi.org/10.1080/15740773. 2016.1260817)
- Hölscher, T., 1987: Römische Bildsprache als semantisches System, Heidelberg (Abhandlungen der Heidelberger Akademie der Wissenschaften, phil.-hist. Klasse 1987 Nr. 2).
- Hölscher, 2018: Visual power in ancient Greece and Rome. Between art and social reality, Oakland 2018.
- Zanker, P., 1988: The power of images in the age of Augustus, Michigan.
- Zanker, P., 2008: Roman art, Los Angeles 2008.
|9.00||Christof Flügel & Martina Meyr||Introduction: Tales of Glory – Roman Vicotry or two Sides of One Coin|
|9.20||Kai Töpfer||Visualizing Roman Power in the provinces – A look at common features and remarkable differences|
|9.40||Edwin Wood||Capricorn in Somerset: an Augustan image at the edge of empire|
|10.00||Michael den Hartog||The Vynen Monument and Commemorating a Greater Victory|
|10.50||Martin Kemkes||It’s all just propaganda? Victoria depictions and inscriptions on the Upper German-Raetian Limes|
|11.10||Monica Gui||Bits and pieces of Rome’s glory in Dacia|
|11.30||Louisa Cambell||Polychromy and Epigraphic Practice in the Provinces: a view from the Antonine Wall|
|11.50||Andrea Meleri||‘Following Baradez’ Traces around the Limes area of the Fountaine des Gazelles (Biskra, Algeria)|
|13.30||Julie Machand & Joachim Le Bomin||The painted iconographic programm of Deir el-Atrash fort: Roman control, protection and military presence in the Egyptian Eastern desert|
|13.50||Eva Steigberger||My face and the Wolf song|
|14.10||David Breeze||Commemorating the Dead|
|14.30||David Breeze||Discussion of the session results|
Visualizing Roman Power in the provinces – A look at common features and remarkable differences
Kai Töpfer, Heidelberg University
Images were an important medium of communication in Roman culture and as such ubiquitous, for instance in the form of public monuments, decorations on everyday objects or in private surroundings. The topics and motifs of these images were no less diverse than their possible uses. An unquestionably important and at the same time very ambivalent topic was the Roman rule and the military superiority of the Roman army. While related images from Rome and Italy, which consistently convey the perspective of the rulers, were a subject of intensive Research, the imagery in the provinces has been investigated less intensively and not comparatively. However, a closer look on such images shows that they differ significantly not only from the imagery in Rome but also from region to region. Therefore the main focus of my paper will be on the question whether these provincial images and the mentioned differences can be understood as an expression of a specific regional perspective on Roman rule. Important factors to be considered in this context are for instance the initiators and their social context as well as regional artistic and visual traditions. Taking these aspects into account, a few exemplary monuments from the eastern Mediterranean provinces and, in comparison, from the Germanic provinces will be examined more closely.
Capricorn in Somerset: an Augustan image at the edge of empire
Edwin Wood on behalf of John Pearce, Dept of Classics, King’s College London
The discovery in 2012 of a copper-alloy figurine of Capricorn in north Somerset, south-west England, exemplifies the replication in the remotest provinces of images derived from the Augustan repertoire defined by Zanker. The figure serves as case study in investigating the mechanism by which such images might be replicated. Stylization of the figure’s details make it likely that it was made in north-west Europe, perhaps in Britain. Comparison with other representations of this motif shows that this Somerset zodiac figure is not easily paralleled in terms of medium or scale. Its likely votive purpose, as a single discrete image or a component of a larger ensemble, is advocated. Based on the context of its findspot, close to the mineral-rich Mendip hills, two scenarios are presented to explain the dissemination of this specific image, one ‘military’, the other ‘civilian’. The discovery was made near Charterhouse, a key centre for mineral extraction in the Mendips after AD 43. Here imperial interest and military involvement are attested in stamped lead ingots and an adjacent fort in the mid-first century AD. Drawing on other representations of Capricorn in text and image from military sites in Britain and beyond, a possible association with the sacellum of a garrison, perhaps comprising soldiers from the second legion Augusta, is proposed. North Somerset is also rich in temples, the most famous being the sanctuary of Sulis Minerva at Bath, where the influence of Augustan iconography on the temple pediment relief has long been argued. Surviving evidence from other temples in the same region shows Roman influence on images and writing as forms of religious devotion, perhaps centred on Bath as a centre of new practice. In this context Capricorn can be alternatively identified as an offering at a local shrine.
The Vynen Monument and Commemorating a Greater Victory
Michael den Hartog, Province of Noord Brabant, Cultural Heritage Programme
As Paul Zanker has shown, Augustus did much to create his image as a successful and victorious ruler. When they came to power, the Flavians followed Augustus’ example and initiated among others an extensive building programme. Victories make good propaganda. Ever since the end of the 1970s, when it was unearthed at Vynen near Xanten, a stone dedicated to Emperor Vespasian and his son Titus has been seen as part of a monument commemorating a triumph of Legio VI Victrix over the Batavians during their epic revolt. In contrast to the much celebrated Flavian capture of Jerusalem, Zangenberg sees the Vynen monument as the only tangible commemoration of their victory over the Batavians. The Vynen monument may seem an isolated find, but it is not alone in the world of Roman epigraphy and Flavian visual propaganda. The object dating to AD 72-73 can be seen as part of a series of building inscriptions along the Roman Limes from the river Rhine to the Euphrates in the honour of Vespasian and Titus. The Vynen inscription also names Aulus Marius Celsus, the governor of the military district of Germania Inferior. Building inscriptions are a means of propaganda for Roman emperors. What role did the stone play in Flavian propaganda as a whole and Flavian propaganda in Germania Inferior in particular? In the turbulent AD 68-70 period the Flavians routed their Vitellian adversaries and installed a new dynasty in Rome. Besides the restoration of fortifications after the Batavian revolt, a thorough restructuring of the legions along the Rhine Limes took place. What did this restructuring look like? What was Aulus Marius Celsus’ role? Coins are another means of propaganda. What kind of information can coinage from the legionary camp at Nijmegen add to the understanding of Flavian propaganda and the stone itself?
It’s all just propaganda? Victoria depictions and inscriptions on the Upper German-Raetian Limes
Martin Kemkes, Archäologisches Landesmuseum Baden-Württemberg
During the current excavations in the western fort of Öhringen in summer 2020, several statue fragments were found in the fort ditch in front of the south gate. Among them was a winged Victoria, which could have originally been part of the decoration of the fort gate. It most likely belonged to the official representational equipment of the fort and symbolized the absolute claim to victory and rule of the Roman army, but also of the entire Roman state. Depictions and inscriptions of the goddess Victoria are widespread along the Limes and in the hinterland. They are found, often in connection with Mars, not only in military contexts as evidence of Roman state and army religion, but also in civilian or private milieus. Apparently, the Roman goddess of victory in her Greco-Roman statue schemes was linked to local religious ideas in the course of an “Interpretatio Romana”. Based on the new find of the statue from Öhringen, the lecture will present the depictions and inscriptions of Victoria at the Upper German-Raetian Limes and discuss the complex appropriation processes of the goddess Victoria in the provinces of Upper Germany and Raetia.
Bits and pieces of Rome’s glory in Dacia
Monica Gui, National Museum of Transylvanian History, Cluj-Napoca
Surely, the idea of Rome’s glory had to be instilled not only in the core of the Empire, but also in its periphery, not least in the military communities on the borders. Images were a powerful tool for its conceptualisation. In Dacia, due to its status of marginal and relatively short-lived Roman province, but probably mostly to modern causes, traces of more or less monumental imagery of this kind are conspicuously scarce. However, they are not altogether absent and allow a glimpse into how the idea of Rome’s victory was conceived and displayed. This very partial picture can be supplemented by similar, significant images recurring on more trivial objects, which are often ignored and/or considered self-evident. Large- and small-scale images were indeed complementary, some alluding more at targeted transmission, while others more at reception. The presentation will focus on a set of well-known symbols closely associated with this message and follow their expression in a variety of media. Questions such as inspiration, production and diffusion of image-bearing objects and monuments and the appropriation of these symbols will be addressed. It will be argued that in the particular context of Dacia’s military environment, the visual vocabulary was rather straightforward, even ‘iconic’ (i.e. immediately recognisable), generally lacking the complexities and nuances seen, for instance, in metropolitan architectural and artistic creations. Even at this basic level, the evidence suggests that it must have worked. Investigating how these tropes were potentially used, interpreted and combined (and by who) to articulate the narrative of Rome’s greatness and invincibility can reveal glimpses of the ideological landscape of the province and some of the factors that actively shaped it.
Polychromy and Epigraphic Practice in the Provinces: a view from the Antonine Wall
Louisa Campbell, University of Glasgow
Unique inscribed reliefs from the Antonine Wall, commonly referred to as Distance Sculptures, provide an exceptional lens through which to view epigraphic and propaganda practices on the edge of Empire. These monuments performed a pivotal role in projecting and maintaining Imperial power over the region and this paper will discuss how recent non-invasive analysis revealed previously invisible pigments that once brought these iconic sculptures to life for both Roman and non-Roman audiences. Vibrant colour imbued the inscribed text, iconography and decorative details with an incredibly powerful additional layer of meaning and a restricted palette of pigments was evidently prescriptively applied to different features making their intended messages widely accessible. However, elemental and mineral fingerprinting of pigment compounds confirms selectivity in the way Roman artisans achieved their desired effects on the Distance Sculptures by applying alternatives that were probably more readily available to them on the frontier. Attempts to reconstruct polychromy on plaster cast replicas have encouraged contemporary audiences to re-imagine and re-engage with Classical statuary they have previously been conditioned to see in pristine white marble, but these representations commonly lack authenticity. This paper demonstrates how emerging analytical and digital technologies now combine to permit more realistic digital reconstructions and interpretive explorations of the impact and performance of these unique monuments in their original, colourful, condition.
Following Baradez’s tracks around the area of Fontaine des Gazelles (Biskra, Algeria)
Andrea Meleri, University of Padova
The aero-photographical and ground surveys conducted by Jean Baradez in the 1940s, later published in his Fossatum Africae, are an often overlooked source of information about the rich and complex network of archeological sites around the roman limes area of Biskra (Vescera) in Algeria. An effort was made to georeference in GIS most of the published Baradez aerial photos against modern satellite imagery and other sources, leading to the potential (re)discovery of many archeological sites. Some of these sites were found and surveyed during two short archeological campaigns conducted in 2018 and 2019. This contribution presents some preliminary findings, along with specific examples highlighting both the quality and the conservation risks of these sites, often located in the vicinity of recently developing peri-Saharan areas.
The painted iconographic programm of Deir el-Atrash fort: Roman control, protection and military presence in the Egyptian Eastern desert
Julie Marchand, Mission archéologique française du désert Oriental; HiSoMA et ASM, CNRS & Joachim Le Bomin, MAFDO; HiSoMA et ASM, CNRS
In January 2020, within the framework of the French Archaeological mission in the Egyptian Eastern Desert (MAFDO), a unique painting of its kind was discovered in Deir el-Atrash fort, build along the desert road that connects Qena in the Nile Valley to ‘Abu Sha’ar on the Red Sea. This praesidium, excavated and studied by the speakers, is the nearest hydreuma located a few stations before the famous Porphyrites quarries. The coloured scenes extend over nearly 2.4 linear meters on the eastern tower of the fort entrance and on the curtain wall and are dated to the Antonine period. The program includes a rider (hero equitans, perhaps Heron, or a draconarius?) and at least three dromedaries led by a camel driver, identified as a dromedarius or a man in charge of supplies. This unique and well-preserved example of figurative scenes painted on the walls of an Egyptian Eastern desert fortress offers a glimpse of a program presented at the entrance of a military device, which clearly symbolizes Rome’s mark and control over the margins of the Empire. After the presentation of the archaeological remains and the painting, the speakers will attempt to highlight all the aspects and questions that are associated with this discovery.
“My face and the Wolf song”
Eva Steigberger, Monuments Authority Austria
The Roman Army was and is considered to be one of the key players in transporting Roman glory into the Empire. Roman military equipment not only serves the purpose of protecting and fighting, it shows Rome’s Might and Power and is supposed to put fear into their enemy. Roman equites, as known, were an impressive sight, dressed in shiny armour telling tales of Roman virtus. A new face mask from Carnuntum with its other finds and the Ribchester helmet are fine examples of the exquisite technique, the care and the love for the equipment, which converts the bearer into the ideal victorious hero of battle sent by the Emperor.
Commemorating the Dead
War memorials and representations of victory at the Edge of Empires This presentation will compare and contrast how the Roman Empire and the British Empire commemorated victory and defeat in monuments. Particular monuments will include Adamklissi and the Antonine Wall, and memorials erected in the 19th century after continental and colonial wars as well as the First World War.